My Media
Watchlist
Sign In

Should I Marry a Murderer?Part 2

TV-MA
S1 • E2    Apr 29, 2026    44m
7.17.2
Add Show to Watchlist
Mark as Watched
As Caroline's actions give police a new lead in a cold case, she enters a terrifying double life with the McKellars — and hopes Sandy still trusts her.
Directed by Josh Allott

Where to Watch Should I Marry a Murderer? - S1 • E2

Cast of Part 2

  • Caroline MuirheadSelf
  • Sandy McKellarSelf (archive footage)
  • Stephen MuirheadSelf – Caroline's Father
  • Margaret MuirheadSelf – Caroline's Mother
  • Ninon NoiretCaroline Muirhead
  • James CrouchSandy McKellar
  • Robert McKellarSelf (archive footage)
  • Tony ParsonsSelf (archive footage)

Get Plex on Your Devices

Free on 20+ platforms. Pick yours.
App StoreiOS & Apple TV
Google PlayAndroid
TVFire TV, Roku & more
See all supported devices →